Skip to content
DEENESFRIT Track order Free shipping in Europe
— Buying Guide

What We Would Never Recommend to a Beginner — and Why

By Tapadum · · 8 min read
An oud, baglama and handpan arranged in an editorial studio composition

In brief: We do not think there is a universally “wrong” first instrument. But we would not recommend a choice that ignores the music you want to play, the room you live in, the maintenance you can realistically handle or the support you will need in the first weeks. A good beginner instrument is not necessarily the cheapest or the most advanced one. It is the one that makes returning to practice easier.

First instrument advice is often reduced to a list of “easy” instruments. That can be useful, but it misses the real decision. A beginner does not need an instrument with the lowest possible barrier in the abstract. They need one whose sound, physical feel and practical demands fit the life they actually have.

At Tapadum, we would not call an instrument unsuitable simply because it is demanding, specialised or made for an experienced player. Those qualities can be exactly right for someone with a clear musical direction. The problem begins when a first purchase is chosen for the wrong reason: a label, a price tag, an image or an assumption that more complexity will automatically create faster progress.

This is not a blacklist. It is a set of situations where we would pause the purchase conversation, ask a few more questions and guide the player toward a better starting point.

We would not recommend choosing only by the lowest price

A low price can be an important part of a real budget, and there is nothing wrong with setting one. But the cheapest available instrument is not automatically the most economical first instrument. If it does not stay in tune, feels uncomfortable to hold, arrives without a clear tuning plan or does not suit the music the player hopes to learn, the saving can disappear in frustration.

The better question is not “What is the cheapest instrument?” It is “What will let me make a recognisable sound and come back to it tomorrow?” For some players, that may be a compact hand drum. For another, it may be an oud with practical tuning hardware. For someone drawn to the santur, it may mean first understanding the tuning layout and the care the instrument needs rather than buying wire or accessories before the instrument itself is clear.

Budget should set a sensible boundary. It should not replace the rest of the decision.

We would not recommend buying a “professional” instrument to solve uncertainty

“Professional” can describe materials, construction, response or a level of musical ambition. It does not answer the beginner’s main questions: What repertoire do I want to play? What tuning will I use? Do I need an acoustic instrument, an amplified one or something I can practise quietly? Can I carry and care for it comfortably?

For example, a professional instrument may be the right choice for a committed student who already knows the sound and musical tradition they want to pursue. But it is not a substitute for choosing a direction. Spending more cannot decide whether a player is looking for Turkish or Arabic oud repertoire, short-neck or long-neck baglama, or the open-ended exploration of a handpan.

We would rather help a new player identify the first useful constraint than encourage an expensive shortcut. A clear musical aim gives an advanced instrument a purpose. Without that aim, a simpler and more direct model is often the better teacher.

We would not recommend an instrument whose musical language does not match the player’s goal

Many traditional instruments appear similar from a distance but ask different things of the player. A choice becomes difficult when the player wants one musical language and buys into another because the names, shapes or prices looked close enough.

Baglama is a clear example. The first decision is not whether the instrument is “beginner” or “professional.” It is whether short-neck or long-neck baglama fits the repertoire and playing approach the person wants to learn. Our first baglama guide explains why short-neck is a practical standard for many new players, while long-neck remains the right choice for players who specifically want its repertory and layout.

The same principle applies to the oud. A first-time player should decide whether they are drawn toward Turkish or Arabic repertoire before treating the instrument as a generic lute. Bridge type, tuning approach and the sound they hope to hear all matter more than a broad label. The beginner oud guide is designed around that decision rather than a one-size-fits-all ranking.

There is no penalty for choosing a specialised instrument as a beginner. The only mistake is choosing it without knowing what it is specialised for.

We would not recommend ignoring the room where the instrument will live

An instrument is not used in a catalogue. It is used in a flat, a family home, a rehearsal space, a studio, a classroom or a shared room. Volume, storage, transport and daily access affect whether practice becomes a habit.

A player who needs to practise late at night may need a different solution from someone who has a dedicated room. A musician who travels on public transport has different priorities from someone whose instrument stays at home. A fragile or easily damaged instrument may be completely suitable when a player has a safe case, stable conditions and time for care; without those things, it can become a source of anxiety instead of music.

This is why we encourage beginners to think about the first month, not only the first photograph. Where will the instrument rest? How will it travel? Who else will hear it? Is there a simple routine for tuning, wiping it down and putting it away safely? Our guide to the first 24 hours with a new instrument helps turn those questions into a practical arrival routine.

We would not recommend a complex setup without a support plan

Every instrument has a learning curve. Some ask for more setup knowledge from the start: tuning, strings, reeds, bridges, skin heads, pickups or a particular playing position. None of this makes an instrument inappropriate. It simply means the player should know where help will come from when the first question appears.

A new santur player, for instance, does not need to be afraid of tuning or string care. But they should understand the instrument’s bridge layout, keep a reliable tuner nearby and know that replacing one broken wire is different from rebuilding the whole instrument. Our santur string guide explains the routine clearly. The same logic applies to a ney player learning to work with breath and embouchure, or to a handpan player learning the role of scale and touch.

The aim is not to remove every difficulty. It is to make sure the first difficulty is one the player is ready to meet.

We would not recommend buying an instrument only because it looks familiar

Familiarity can be helpful, but it can also hide an unexpected difference. A player coming from guitar may assume every long-neck lute will respond in the same way. Someone who has seen a handpan online may expect it to work like a small drum. A buyer who has heard an oud in recordings may not realise how much tuning, string courses and repertoire shape the first experience.

Before buying, listen to a real sound sample, look at the instrument from more than one angle and ask what a first lesson or first practice session will actually involve. If the answer still feels exciting, the unfamiliarity is not a warning; it is part of the reason to begin.

For players considering a handpan, scale matters more than colour or surface finish. A first handpan guide can help separate the musical decision from the visual one. For a hand drum, posture, volume and the kind of rhythm a player wants to make are more useful starting points than a generic promise of “easy.”

What we do recommend instead

We recommend beginning with a short conversation and five honest answers:

  • What music do you want to hear yourself playing? A reference recording is more useful than a vague category.
  • Where will you practise? The room and neighbours matter as much as the instrument.
  • How much setup feels realistic? Be honest about tuning, care and time.
  • What will keep you motivated after the first week? A favourite sound, a simple rhythm or a clear song can all be valid answers.
  • Who can help if you get stuck? A teacher, an experienced friend, a maker or a reliable guide changes the first month completely.

Those answers do not produce one universal recommendation. They produce a useful direction. From there, the instrument can be chosen for its voice, build and practical fit rather than for a promise that it will make learning effortless.

Frequently asked questions

Is an expensive instrument always a better first instrument?

No. A higher price may reflect materials, construction or a more specialised design, but it does not replace the need to choose an instrument that suits your repertoire, room and practical needs.

Should a beginner avoid instruments that need tuning or maintenance?

No. Every instrument needs some care. The important question is whether you understand the basic routine and have a clear source of help for the first adjustment, string change or tuning question.

Is short-neck baglama always better for a beginner?

Not always. It is a practical starting point for many players, but the right choice depends on the repertoire and musical approach you want to learn.

Can a beginner start with a professional instrument?

Yes, if the player already knows why that instrument fits their musical goal and practical situation. “Professional” should be a meaningful choice, not a substitute for choosing a direction.

What should I ask before buying my first traditional instrument online?

Ask for a current sound sample, the instrument’s actual measurements and tuning, clear close-up photographs, a description of what is included and practical advice for the first days of ownership.

Start with the right questions

If you are choosing your first traditional instrument, tell us the music you want to play, where you will practise and what kind of sound draws you in. We can help you narrow the field before you choose.

About the contributor

Ozgur Yalcin is the founder of Tapadum and the Kara Gunes music group. His work brings musicians, makers and traditional instruments into the same practical conversation: not only how an instrument is made, but how it enters a player’s musical life.